xref: /freebsd/sys/netinet/libalias/libalias.3 (revision 2e3507c25e42292b45a5482e116d278f5515d04d)
1.\"-
2.\" Copyright (c) 2001 Charles Mott <cm@linktel.net>
3.\" All rights reserved.
4.\"
5.\" Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without
6.\" modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions
7.\" are met:
8.\" 1. Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright
9.\"    notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer.
10.\" 2. Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright
11.\"    notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer in the
12.\"    documentation and/or other materials provided with the distribution.
13.\"
14.\" THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED BY THE AUTHOR AND CONTRIBUTORS ``AS IS'' AND
15.\" ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE
16.\" IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE
17.\" ARE DISCLAIMED.  IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHOR OR CONTRIBUTORS BE LIABLE
18.\" FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, EXEMPLARY, OR CONSEQUENTIAL
19.\" DAMAGES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, PROCUREMENT OF SUBSTITUTE GOODS
20.\" OR SERVICES; LOSS OF USE, DATA, OR PROFITS; OR BUSINESS INTERRUPTION)
21.\" HOWEVER CAUSED AND ON ANY THEORY OF LIABILITY, WHETHER IN CONTRACT, STRICT
22.\" LIABILITY, OR TORT (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE OR OTHERWISE) ARISING IN ANY WAY
23.\" OUT OF THE USE OF THIS SOFTWARE, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF
24.\" SUCH DAMAGE.
25.\"
26.Dd May 31, 2021
27.Dt LIBALIAS 3
28.Os
29.Sh NAME
30.Nm libalias
31.Nd packet aliasing library for masquerading and network address translation
32.Sh SYNOPSIS
33.In sys/types.h
34.In netinet/in.h
35.In alias.h
36.Pp
37Function prototypes are given in the main body of the text.
38.Sh DESCRIPTION
39The
40.Nm
41library is a collection of functions for aliasing and de-aliasing of IP
42packets, intended for masquerading and network address translation (NAT).
43.Sh INTRODUCTION
44This library is a moderately portable set of functions designed to assist
45in the process of IP masquerading and network address translation.
46Outgoing packets from a local network with unregistered IP addresses can
47be aliased to appear as if they came from an accessible IP address.
48Incoming packets are then de-aliased so that they are sent to the correct
49machine on the local network.
50.Pp
51A certain amount of flexibility is built into the packet aliasing engine.
52In the simplest mode of operation, a many-to-one address mapping takes
53place between the local network and the packet aliasing host.
54This is known as IP masquerading.
55In addition, one-to-one mappings between local and public addresses can
56also be implemented, which is known as static NAT.
57In between these extremes, different groups of private addresses can be
58linked to different public addresses, comprising several distinct
59many-to-one mappings.
60Also, a given public address and port can be statically redirected to a
61private address/port.
62.Sh INITIALIZATION AND CONTROL
63One special function,
64.Fn LibAliasInit ,
65must always be called before any packet handling may be performed, and
66the returned instance pointer must be passed to all the other functions.
67Normally, the
68.Fn LibAliasSetAddress
69function is called afterwards, to set the default aliasing address.
70In addition, the operating mode of the packet aliasing engine can be
71customized by calling
72.Fn LibAliasSetMode .
73.Pp
74.Ft "struct libalias *"
75.Fn LibAliasInit "struct libalias *"
76.Bd -ragged -offset indent
77This function is used to initialize
78internal data structures.
79When called the first time, a
80.Dv NULL
81pointer should be passed as an argument.
82The following mode bits are always set after calling
83.Fn LibAliasInit .
84See the description of
85.Fn LibAliasSetMode
86below for the meaning of these mode bits.
87.Pp
88.Bl -item -offset indent -compact
89.It
90.Dv PKT_ALIAS_SAME_PORTS
91.It
92.Dv PKT_ALIAS_USE_SOCKETS
93.It
94.Dv PKT_ALIAS_RESET_ON_ADDR_CHANGE
95.El
96.Pp
97This function will always return the packet aliasing engine to the same
98initial state.
99The
100.Fn LibAliasSetAddress
101function is normally called afterwards, and any desired changes from the
102default mode bits listed above require a call to
103.Fn LibAliasSetMode .
104.Pp
105It is mandatory that this function be called at the beginning of a program
106prior to any packet handling.
107.Ed
108.Pp
109.Ft void
110.Fn LibAliasUninit "struct libalias *"
111.Bd -ragged -offset indent
112This function has no return value and is used to clear any
113resources attached to internal data structures.
114.Pp
115This function should be called when a program stops using the aliasing
116engine; amongst other things, it clears out any firewall holes.
117To provide backwards compatibility and extra security, it is added to
118the
119.Xr atexit 3
120chain by
121.Fn LibAliasInit .
122.Ed
123.Pp
124.Ft void
125.Fn LibAliasSetAddress "struct libalias *" "struct in_addr addr"
126.Bd -ragged -offset indent
127This function sets the source address to which outgoing packets from the
128local area network are aliased.
129All outgoing packets are re-mapped to this address unless overridden by a
130static address mapping established by
131.Fn LibAliasRedirectAddr .
132If this function has not been called, and no static rules match, an outgoing
133packet retains its source address.
134.Pp
135If the
136.Dv PKT_ALIAS_RESET_ON_ADDR_CHANGE
137mode bit is set (the default mode of operation), then the internal aliasing
138link tables will be reset any time the aliasing address changes.
139This is useful for interfaces such as
140.Xr ppp 8 ,
141where the IP
142address may or may not change on successive dial-up attempts.
143.Pp
144If the
145.Dv PKT_ALIAS_RESET_ON_ADDR_CHANGE
146mode bit is set to zero, this function can also be used to dynamically change
147the aliasing address on a packet-to-packet basis (it is a low overhead call).
148.Pp
149It is mandatory that this function be called prior to any packet handling.
150.Ed
151.Pp
152.Ft unsigned int
153.Fn LibAliasSetMode "struct libalias *" "unsigned int flags" "unsigned int mask"
154.Bd -ragged -offset indent
155This function sets or clears mode bits
156according to the value of
157.Fa flags .
158Only bits marked in
159.Fa mask
160are affected.
161The following mode bits are defined in
162.In alias.h :
163.Bl -tag -width indent
164.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_LOG
165Enables logging into
166.Pa /var/log/alias.log .
167Each time an aliasing link is created or deleted, the log file is appended to
168with the current number of ICMP, TCP and UDP links.
169Mainly useful for debugging when the log file is viewed continuously with
170.Xr tail 1 .
171.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_DENY_INCOMING
172If this mode bit is set, all incoming packets associated with new TCP
173connections or new UDP transactions will be marked for being ignored
174.Po
175.Fn LibAliasIn
176returns
177.Dv PKT_ALIAS_IGNORED
178code
179.Pc
180by the calling program.
181Response packets to connections or transactions initiated from the packet
182aliasing host or local network will be unaffected.
183This mode bit is useful for implementing a one-way firewall.
184.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_SAME_PORTS
185If this mode bit is set, the packet-aliasing engine will attempt to leave
186the alias port numbers unchanged from the actual local port numbers.
187This can be done as long as the quintuple (proto, alias addr, alias port,
188remote addr, remote port) is unique.
189If a conflict exists, a new aliasing port number is chosen even if this
190mode bit is set.
191.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_USE_SOCKETS
192This bit should be set when the packet aliasing host originates network
193traffic as well as forwards it.
194When the packet aliasing host is waiting for a connection from an unknown
195host address or unknown port number (e.g.\& an FTP data connection), this
196mode bit specifies that a socket be allocated as a place holder to prevent
197port conflicts.
198Once a connection is established, usually within a minute or so, the socket
199is closed.
200.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_UNREGISTERED_ONLY
201If this mode bit is set, traffic on the local network which does not
202originate from unregistered address spaces will be ignored.
203Standard Class A, B and C unregistered addresses are:
204.Pp
20510.0.0.0     ->  10.255.255.255   (Class A subnet)
206172.16.0.0   ->  172.31.255.255   (Class B subnets)
207192.168.0.0  ->  192.168.255.255  (Class C subnets)
208.Pp
209This option is useful in the case that the packet aliasing host has both
210registered and unregistered subnets on different interfaces.
211The registered subnet is fully accessible to the outside world, so traffic
212from it does not need to be passed through the packet aliasing engine.
213.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_UNREGISTERED_CGN
214Like PKT_ALIAS_UNREGISTERED_ONLY, but includes the RFC 6598 (Carrier Grade
215NAT) subnet as follows:
216.Pp
217100.64.0.0   ->  100.127.255.255  (RFC 6598 subnet)
218.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_RESET_ON_ADDR_CHANGE
219When this mode bit is set and
220.Fn LibAliasSetAddress
221is called to change the aliasing address, the internal link table of the
222packet aliasing engine will be cleared.
223This operating mode is useful for
224.Xr ppp 8
225links where the interface address can sometimes change or remain the same
226between dial-up attempts.
227If this mode bit is not set, the link table will never be reset in the event
228of an address change.
229.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_PUNCH_FW
230This option makes
231.Nm
232.Dq punch holes
233in an
234.Xr ipfirewall 4 -
235based firewall for FTP/IRC DCC connections.
236The holes punched are bound by from/to IP address and port; it will not be
237possible to use a hole for another connection.
238A hole is removed when the connection that uses it dies.
239To cater to unexpected death of a program using
240.Nm
241(e.g.\& kill -9),
242changing the state of the flag will clear the entire firewall range
243allocated for holes.
244This clearing will also happen on the initial call to
245.Fn LibAliasSetFWBase ,
246which must happen prior to setting this flag.
247.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_REVERSE
248This option makes
249.Nm
250reverse the way it handles incoming and outgoing packets, allowing it
251to be fed with data that passes through the internal interface rather
252than the external one.
253.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_PROXY_ONLY
254This option tells
255.Nm
256to obey transparent proxy rules only.
257Normal packet aliasing is not performed.
258See
259.Fn LibAliasProxyRule
260below for details.
261.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_SKIP_GLOBAL
262This option is used by
263.Pa ipfw_nat
264only.
265Specifying it as a flag to
266.Fn LibAliasSetMode
267has no effect.
268See section
269.Sx NETWORK ADDRESS TRANSLATION
270in
271.Xr ipfw 8
272for more details.
273.El
274.Ed
275.Pp
276.Ft void
277.Fn LibAliasSetFWBase "struct libalias *" "unsigned int base" "unsigned int num"
278.Bd -ragged -offset indent
279Set the firewall range allocated for punching firewall holes (with the
280.Dv PKT_ALIAS_PUNCH_FW
281flag).
282The range is cleared for all rules on initialization.
283.Ed
284.Pp
285.Ft void
286.Fn LibAliasSkinnyPort "struct libalias *" "unsigned int port"
287.Bd -ragged -offset indent
288Set the TCP port used by the Skinny Station protocol.
289Skinny is used by Cisco IP phones to communicate with
290Cisco Call Managers to set up voice over IP calls.
291If this is not set, Skinny aliasing will not be done.
292The typical port used by Skinny is 2000.
293.Ed
294.Sh PACKET HANDLING
295The packet handling functions are used to modify incoming (remote to local)
296and outgoing (local to remote) packets.
297The calling program is responsible for receiving and sending packets via
298network interfaces.
299.Pp
300Along with
301.Fn LibAliasInit
302and
303.Fn LibAliasSetAddress ,
304the two packet handling functions,
305.Fn LibAliasIn
306and
307.Fn LibAliasOut ,
308comprise the minimal set of functions needed for a basic IP masquerading
309implementation.
310.Pp
311.Ft int
312.Fn LibAliasIn "struct libalias *" "void *buffer" "int maxpacketsize"
313.Bd -ragged -offset indent
314An incoming packet coming from a remote machine to the local network is
315de-aliased by this function.
316The IP packet is pointed to by
317.Fa buffer ,
318and
319.Fa maxpacketsize
320indicates the size of the data structure containing the packet and should
321be at least as large as the actual packet size.
322.Pp
323Return codes:
324.Bl -tag -width indent
325.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_OK
326The packet aliasing process was successful.
327.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_IGNORED
328The packet was ignored and not de-aliased.
329This can happen if the protocol is unrecognized, as for an ICMP message
330type that is not handled, or if incoming packets for new connections are being
331ignored (if the
332.Dv PKT_ALIAS_DENY_INCOMING
333mode bit was set using
334.Fn LibAliasSetMode ) .
335.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_UNRESOLVED_FRAGMENT
336This is returned when a fragment cannot be resolved because the header
337fragment has not been sent yet.
338In this situation, fragments must be saved with
339.Fn LibAliasSaveFragment
340until a header fragment is found.
341.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_FOUND_HEADER_FRAGMENT
342The packet aliasing process was successful, and a header fragment was found.
343This is a signal to retrieve any unresolved fragments with
344.Fn LibAliasGetFragment
345and de-alias them with
346.Fn LibAliasFragmentIn .
347.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_ERROR
348An internal error within the packet aliasing engine occurred.
349.El
350.Ed
351.Pp
352.Ft int
353.Fn LibAliasOut "struct libalias *" "void *buffer" "int maxpacketsize"
354.Bd -ragged -offset indent
355An outgoing packet coming from the local network to a remote machine is
356aliased by this function.
357The IP packet is pointed to by
358.Fa buffer ,
359and
360.Fa maxpacketsize
361indicates the maximum packet size permissible should the packet length be
362changed.
363IP encoding protocols place address and port information in the encapsulated
364data stream which has to be modified and can account for changes in packet
365length.
366Well known examples of such protocols are FTP and IRC DCC.
367.Pp
368Return codes:
369.Bl -tag -width indent
370.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_OK
371The packet aliasing process was successful.
372.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_IGNORED
373The packet was ignored and not aliased.
374This can happen if the protocol is unrecognized, or possibly an ICMP message
375type is not handled.
376.It Dv PKT_ALIAS_ERROR
377An internal error within the packet aliasing engine occurred.
378.El
379.Ed
380.Sh PORT AND ADDRESS REDIRECTION
381The functions described in this section allow machines on the local network
382to be accessible in some degree to new incoming connections from the external
383network.
384Individual ports can be re-mapped or static network address translations can
385be designated.
386.Pp
387.Ft struct alias_link *
388.Fo LibAliasRedirectPort
389.Fa "struct libalias *"
390.Fa "struct in_addr local_addr"
391.Fa "u_short local_port"
392.Fa "struct in_addr remote_addr"
393.Fa "u_short remote_port"
394.Fa "struct in_addr alias_addr"
395.Fa "u_short alias_port"
396.Fa "u_char proto"
397.Fc
398.Bd -ragged -offset indent
399This function specifies that traffic from a given remote address/port to
400an alias address/port be redirected to a specified local address/port.
401The parameter
402.Fa proto
403can be either
404.Dv IPPROTO_TCP
405or
406.Dv IPPROTO_UDP ,
407as defined in
408.In netinet/in.h .
409.Pp
410If
411.Fa local_addr
412or
413.Fa alias_addr
414is zero, this indicates that the packet aliasing address as established
415by
416.Fn LibAliasSetAddress
417is to be used.
418Even if
419.Fn LibAliasSetAddress
420is called to change the address after
421.Fn LibAliasRedirectPort
422is called, a zero reference will track this change.
423.Pp
424If the link is further set up to operate with load sharing, then
425.Fa local_addr
426and
427.Fa local_port
428are ignored, and are selected dynamically from the server pool, as described in
429.Fn LibAliasAddServer
430below.
431.Pp
432If
433.Fa remote_addr
434is zero, this indicates to redirect packets from any remote address.
435Likewise, if
436.Fa remote_port
437is zero, this indicates to redirect packets originating from any remote
438port number.
439The remote port specification will almost always be zero, but non-zero
440remote addresses can sometimes be useful for firewalling.
441If two calls to
442.Fn LibAliasRedirectPort
443overlap in their address/port specifications, then the most recent call
444will have precedence.
445.Pp
446This function returns a pointer which can subsequently be used by
447.Fn LibAliasRedirectDelete .
448If
449.Dv NULL
450is returned, then the function call did not complete successfully.
451.Pp
452All port numbers should be in network address byte order, so it is necessary
453to use
454.Xr htons 3
455to convert these parameters from internally readable numbers to network byte
456order.
457Addresses are also in network byte order, which is implicit in the use of the
458.Fa struct in_addr
459data type.
460.Ed
461.Pp
462.Ft struct alias_link *
463.Fo LibAliasRedirectAddr
464.Fa "struct libalias *"
465.Fa "struct in_addr local_addr"
466.Fa "struct in_addr alias_addr"
467.Fc
468.Bd -ragged -offset indent
469This function designates that all incoming traffic to
470.Fa alias_addr
471be redirected to
472.Fa local_addr .
473Similarly, all outgoing traffic from
474.Fa local_addr
475is aliased to
476.Fa alias_addr .
477.Pp
478If
479.Fa local_addr
480or
481.Fa alias_addr
482is zero, this indicates that the packet aliasing address as established by
483.Fn LibAliasSetAddress
484is to be used.
485Even if
486.Fn LibAliasSetAddress
487is called to change the address after
488.Fn LibAliasRedirectAddr
489is called, a zero reference will track this change.
490.Pp
491If the link is further set up to operate with load sharing, then the
492.Fa local_addr
493argument is ignored, and is selected dynamically from the server pool,
494as described in
495.Fn LibAliasAddServer
496below.
497.Pp
498If subsequent calls to
499.Fn LibAliasRedirectAddr
500use the same aliasing address, all new incoming traffic to this aliasing
501address will be redirected to the local address made in the last function
502call.
503New traffic generated by any of the local machines, designated in the
504several function calls, will be aliased to the same address.
505Consider the following example:
506.Pp
507LibAliasRedirectAddr(la, inet_aton("192.168.0.2"),
508                        inet_aton("141.221.254.101"));
509LibAliasRedirectAddr(la, inet_aton("192.168.0.3"),
510                        inet_aton("141.221.254.101"));
511LibAliasRedirectAddr(la, inet_aton("192.168.0.4"),
512                        inet_aton("141.221.254.101"));
513.Pp
514Any outgoing connections such as
515.Xr telnet 1
516or
517.Xr ftp 1
518from 192.168.0.2, 192.168.0.3 and 192.168.0.4 will appear to come from
519141.221.254.101.
520Any incoming connections to 141.221.254.101 will be directed to 192.168.0.4.
521.Pp
522Any calls to
523.Fn LibAliasRedirectPort
524will have precedence over address mappings designated by
525.Fn LibAliasRedirectAddr .
526.Pp
527This function returns a pointer which can subsequently be used by
528.Fn LibAliasRedirectDelete .
529If
530.Dv NULL
531is returned, then the function call did not complete successfully.
532.Ed
533.Pp
534.Ft int
535.Fo LibAliasAddServer
536.Fa "struct libalias *"
537.Fa "struct alias_link *link"
538.Fa "struct in_addr addr"
539.Fa "u_short port"
540.Fc
541.Bd -ragged -offset indent
542This function sets the
543.Fa link
544up for Load Sharing using IP Network Address Translation (RFC 2391, LSNAT).
545LSNAT operates as follows.
546A client attempts to access a server by using the server virtual address.
547The LSNAT router transparently redirects the request to one of the hosts
548in the server pool, using a real-time load sharing algorithm.
549Multiple sessions may be initiated from the same client, and each session
550could be directed to a different host based on the load balance across server
551pool hosts when the sessions are initiated.
552If load sharing is desired for just a few specific services, the configuration
553on LSNAT could be defined to restrict load sharing to just the services
554desired.
555.Pp
556Currently, only the simplest selection algorithm is implemented, where a
557host is selected on a round-robin basis only, without regard to load on
558the host.
559.Pp
560First, the
561.Fa link
562is created by either
563.Fn LibAliasRedirectPort
564or
565.Fn LibAliasRedirectAddr .
566Then,
567.Fn LibAliasAddServer
568is called multiple times to add entries to the
569.Fa link Ns 's
570server pool.
571.Pp
572For links created with
573.Fn LibAliasRedirectAddr ,
574the
575.Fa port
576argument is ignored and could have any value, e.g.\& htons(~0).
577.Pp
578This function returns 0 on success, \-1 otherwise.
579.Ed
580.Pp
581.Ft int
582.Fn LibAliasRedirectDynamic "struct libalias *" "struct alias_link *link"
583.Bd -ragged -offset indent
584This function marks the specified static redirect rule entered by
585.Fn LibAliasRedirectPort
586as dynamic.
587This can be used to e.g.\& dynamically redirect a single TCP connection,
588after which the rule is removed.
589Only fully specified links can be made dynamic.
590(See the
591.Sx STATIC AND DYNAMIC LINKS
592and
593.Sx PARTIALLY SPECIFIED ALIASING LINKS
594sections below for a definition of static vs.\& dynamic,
595and partially vs.\& fully specified links.)
596.Pp
597This function returns 0 on success, \-1 otherwise.
598.Ed
599.Pp
600.Ft void
601.Fn LibAliasRedirectDelete "struct libalias *" "struct alias_link *link"
602.Bd -ragged -offset indent
603This function will delete a specific static redirect rule entered by
604.Fn LibAliasRedirectPort
605or
606.Fn LibAliasRedirectAddr .
607The parameter
608.Fa link
609is the pointer returned by either of the redirection functions.
610If an invalid pointer is passed to
611.Fn LibAliasRedirectDelete ,
612then a program crash or unpredictable operation could result, so
613care is needed when using this function.
614.Ed
615.Pp
616.Ft int
617.Fn LibAliasProxyRule "struct libalias *" "const char *cmd"
618.Bd -ragged -offset indent
619The passed
620.Fa cmd
621string consists of one or more pairs of words.
622The first word in each pair is a token and the second is the value that
623should be applied for that token.
624Tokens and their argument types are as follows:
625.Bl -tag -width indent
626.It Cm type encode_ip_hdr | encode_tcp_stream | no_encode
627In order to support transparent proxying, it is necessary to somehow
628pass the original address and port information into the new destination
629server.
630If
631.Cm encode_ip_hdr
632is specified, the original destination address and port are passed
633as an extra IP option.
634If
635.Cm encode_tcp_stream
636is specified, the original destination address and port are passed
637as the first piece of data in the TCP stream in the format
638.Dq Li DEST Ar IP port .
639.It Cm port Ar portnum
640Only packets with the destination port
641.Ar portnum
642are proxied.
643.It Cm server Ar host Ns Op : Ns Ar portnum
644This specifies the
645.Ar host
646and
647.Ar portnum
648that the data is to be redirected to.
649.Ar host
650must be an IP address rather than a DNS host name.
651If
652.Ar portnum
653is not specified, the destination port number is not changed.
654.Pp
655The
656.Ar server
657specification is mandatory unless the
658.Cm delete
659command is being used.
660.It Cm rule Ar index
661Normally, each call to
662.Fn LibAliasProxyRule
663inserts the next rule at the start of a linear list of rules.
664If an
665.Ar index
666is specified, the new rule will be checked after all rules with lower
667indices.
668Calls to
669.Fn LibAliasProxyRule
670that do not specify a rule are assigned rule 0.
671.It Cm delete Ar index
672This token and its argument MUST NOT be used with any other tokens.
673When used, all existing rules with the given
674.Ar index
675are deleted.
676.It Cm proto tcp | udp
677If specified, only packets of the given protocol type are matched.
678.It Cm src Ar IP Ns Op / Ns Ar bits
679If specified, only packets with a source address matching the given
680.Ar IP
681are matched.
682If
683.Ar bits
684is also specified, then the first
685.Ar bits
686bits of
687.Ar IP
688are taken as a network specification, and all IP addresses from that
689network will be matched.
690.It Cm dst Ar IP Ns Op / Ns Ar bits
691If specified, only packets with a destination address matching the given
692.Ar IP
693are matched.
694If
695.Ar bits
696is also specified, then the first
697.Ar bits
698bits of
699.Ar IP
700are taken as a network specification, and all IP addresses from that
701network will be matched.
702.El
703.Pp
704This function is usually used to redirect outgoing connections for
705internal machines that are not permitted certain types of internet
706access, or to restrict access to certain external machines.
707.Ed
708.Pp
709.Ft struct alias_link *
710.Fo LibAliasRedirectProto
711.Fa "struct libalias *"
712.Fa "struct in_addr local_addr"
713.Fa "struct in_addr remote_addr"
714.Fa "struct in_addr alias_addr"
715.Fa "u_char proto"
716.Fc
717.Bd -ragged -offset indent
718This function specifies that any IP packet with protocol number of
719.Fa proto
720from a given remote address to an alias address will be
721redirected to a specified local address.
722.Pp
723If
724.Fa local_addr
725or
726.Fa alias_addr
727is zero, this indicates that the packet aliasing address as established
728by
729.Fn LibAliasSetAddress
730is to be used.
731Even if
732.Fn LibAliasSetAddress
733is called to change the address after
734.Fn LibAliasRedirectProto
735is called, a zero reference will track this change.
736.Pp
737If
738.Fa remote_addr
739is zero, this indicates to redirect packets from any remote address.
740Non-zero remote addresses can sometimes be useful for firewalling.
741.Pp
742If two calls to
743.Fn LibAliasRedirectProto
744overlap in their address specifications, then the most recent call
745will have precedence.
746.Pp
747This function returns a pointer which can subsequently be used by
748.Fn LibAliasRedirectDelete .
749If
750.Dv NULL
751is returned, then the function call did not complete successfully.
752.Ed
753.Sh FRAGMENT HANDLING
754The functions in this section are used to deal with incoming fragments.
755.Pp
756Outgoing fragments are handled within
757.Fn LibAliasOut
758by changing the address according to any applicable mapping set by
759.Fn LibAliasRedirectAddr ,
760or the default aliasing address set by
761.Fn LibAliasSetAddress .
762.Pp
763Incoming fragments are handled in one of two ways.
764If the header of a fragmented IP packet has already been seen, then all
765subsequent fragments will be re-mapped in the same manner the header
766fragment was.
767Fragments which arrive before the header are saved and then retrieved
768once the header fragment has been resolved.
769.Pp
770.Ft int
771.Fn LibAliasSaveFragment "struct libalias *" "void *ptr"
772.Bd -ragged -offset indent
773When
774.Fn LibAliasIn
775returns
776.Dv PKT_ALIAS_UNRESOLVED_FRAGMENT ,
777this function can be used to save the pointer to the unresolved fragment.
778.Pp
779It is implicitly assumed that
780.Fa ptr
781points to a block of memory allocated by
782.Xr malloc 3 .
783If the fragment is never resolved, the packet aliasing engine will
784automatically free the memory after a timeout period.
785[Eventually this function should be modified so that a callback function
786for freeing memory is passed as an argument.]
787.Pp
788This function returns
789.Dv PKT_ALIAS_OK
790if it was successful and
791.Dv PKT_ALIAS_ERROR
792if there was an error.
793.Ed
794.Pp
795.Ft void *
796.Fn LibAliasGetFragment "struct libalias *" "void *buffer"
797.Bd -ragged -offset indent
798This function can be used to retrieve fragment pointers saved by
799.Fn LibAliasSaveFragment .
800The IP header fragment pointed to by
801.Fa buffer
802is the header fragment indicated when
803.Fn LibAliasIn
804returns
805.Dv PKT_ALIAS_FOUND_HEADER_FRAGMENT .
806Once a fragment pointer is retrieved, it becomes the calling program's
807responsibility to free the dynamically allocated memory for the fragment.
808.Pp
809The
810.Fn LibAliasGetFragment
811function can be called sequentially until there are no more fragments
812available, at which time it returns
813.Dv NULL .
814.Ed
815.Pp
816.Ft void
817.Fn LibAliasFragmentIn "struct libalias *" "void *header" "void *fragment"
818.Bd -ragged -offset indent
819When a fragment is retrieved with
820.Fn LibAliasGetFragment ,
821it can then be de-aliased with a call to
822.Fn LibAliasFragmentIn .
823The
824.Fa header
825argument is the pointer to a header fragment used as a template, and
826.Fa fragment
827is the pointer to the packet to be de-aliased.
828.Ed
829.Sh MISCELLANEOUS FUNCTIONS
830.Ft struct alias_link *
831.Fn AddLink "struct libalias *" "struct in_addr src_addr" "struct in_addr dst_addr" \
832"struct in_addr alias_addr" "u_short src_port" "u_short dst_port" \
833"int alias_param" "int link_type"
834.Bd -ragged -offset indent
835This function adds new state to the instance hash table.
836The dst_address and/or dst_port may be given as zero, which
837introduces some dynamic character into the link, since
838LibAliasSetAddress can change the address that is used.
839However, in the current implementation, such links can only be used
840for inbound (ext -> int) traffic.
841.Ed
842.Pp
843.Ft void
844.Fn LibAliasSetTarget "struct libalias *" "struct in_addr addr"
845.Bd -ragged -offset indent
846When an incoming packet not associated with any pre-existing aliasing link
847arrives at the host machine, it will be sent to the address indicated by a
848call to
849.Fn LibAliasSetTarget .
850.Pp
851If this function is called with an
852.Dv INADDR_NONE
853address argument, then all new incoming packets go to the address set by
854.Fn LibAliasSetAddress .
855.Pp
856If this function is not called, or is called with an
857.Dv INADDR_ANY
858address argument, then all new incoming packets go to the address specified
859in the packet.
860This allows external machines to talk directly to internal machines if they
861can route packets to the machine in question.
862.Ed
863.Pp
864.Ft u_short
865.Fn LibAliasInternetChecksum "struct libalias *" "u_short *buffer" "int nbytes"
866.Bd -ragged -offset indent
867This is a utility function that does not seem to be available elsewhere and
868is included as a convenience.
869It computes the internet checksum, which is used in both IP and
870protocol-specific headers (TCP, UDP, ICMP).
871.Pp
872The
873.Fa buffer
874argument points to the data block to be checksummed, and
875.Fa nbytes
876is the number of bytes.
877The 16-bit checksum field should be zeroed before computing the checksum.
878.Pp
879Checksums can also be verified by operating on a block of data including
880its checksum.
881If the checksum is valid,
882.Fn LibAliasInternetChecksum
883will return zero.
884.Ed
885.Pp
886.Ft int
887.Fn LibAliasUnaliasOut "struct libalias *" "void *buffer" "int maxpacketsize"
888.Bd -ragged -offset indent
889An outgoing packet, which has already been aliased,
890has its private address/port information restored by this function.
891The IP packet is pointed to by
892.Fa buffer ,
893and
894.Fa maxpacketsize
895is provided for error checking purposes.
896This function can be used if an already-aliased packet needs to have its
897original IP header restored for further processing (e.g.\& logging).
898.Ed
899.Sh CONCEPTUAL BACKGROUND
900This section is intended for those who are planning to modify the source
901code or want to create somewhat esoteric applications using the packet
902aliasing functions.
903.Pp
904The conceptual framework under which the packet aliasing engine operates
905is described here.
906Central to the discussion is the idea of an
907.Em aliasing link
908which describes the relationship for a given packet transaction between
909the local machine, aliased identity and remote machine.
910It is discussed how such links come into existence and are destroyed.
911.Ss ALIASING LINKS
912There is a notion of an
913.Em aliasing link ,
914which is a 7-tuple describing a specific translation:
915.Bd -literal -offset indent
916(local addr, local port, alias addr, alias port,
917 remote addr, remote port, protocol)
918.Ed
919.Pp
920Outgoing packets have the local address and port number replaced with the
921alias address and port number.
922Incoming packets undergo the reverse process.
923The packet aliasing engine attempts to match packets against an internal
924table of aliasing links to determine how to modify a given IP packet.
925Both the IP header and protocol dependent headers are modified as necessary.
926Aliasing links are created and deleted as necessary according to network
927traffic.
928.Pp
929Protocols can be TCP, UDP or even ICMP in certain circumstances.
930(Some types of ICMP packets can be aliased according to sequence or ID
931number which acts as an equivalent port number for identifying how
932individual packets should be handled.)
933.Pp
934Each aliasing link must have a unique combination of the following five
935quantities: alias address/port, remote address/port and protocol.
936This ensures that several machines on a local network can share the
937same aliasing IP address.
938In cases where conflicts might arise, the aliasing port is chosen so that
939uniqueness is maintained.
940.Ss STATIC AND DYNAMIC LINKS
941Aliasing links can either be static or dynamic.
942Static links persist indefinitely and represent fixed rules for translating
943IP packets.
944Dynamic links come into existence for a specific TCP connection or UDP
945transaction or ICMP ECHO sequence.
946For the case of TCP, the connection can be monitored to see when the
947associated aliasing link should be deleted.
948Aliasing links for UDP transactions (and ICMP ECHO and TIMESTAMP requests)
949work on a simple timeout rule.
950When no activity is observed on a dynamic link for a certain amount of time
951it is automatically deleted.
952Timeout rules also apply to TCP connections which do not open or close
953properly.
954.Ss PARTIALLY SPECIFIED ALIASING LINKS
955Aliasing links can be partially specified, meaning that the remote address
956and/or remote port are unknown.
957In this case, when a packet matching the incomplete specification is found,
958a fully specified dynamic link is created.
959If the original partially specified link is dynamic, it will be deleted
960after the fully specified link is created, otherwise it will persist.
961.Pp
962For instance, a partially specified link might be
963.Bd -literal -offset indent
964(192.168.0.4, 23, 204.228.203.215, 8066, 0, 0, tcp)
965.Ed
966.Pp
967The zeros denote unspecified components for the remote address and port.
968If this link were static it would have the effect of redirecting all
969incoming traffic from port 8066 of 204.228.203.215 to port 23 (telnet)
970of machine 192.168.0.4 on the local network.
971Each individual telnet connection would initiate the creation of a distinct
972dynamic link.
973.Ss DYNAMIC LINK CREATION
974In addition to aliasing links, there are also address mappings that can be
975stored within the internal data table of the packet aliasing mechanism.
976.Bd -literal -offset indent
977(local addr, alias addr)
978.Ed
979.Pp
980Address mappings are searched when creating new dynamic links.
981.Pp
982All outgoing packets from the local network automatically create a dynamic
983link if they do not match an already existing fully specified link.
984If an address mapping exists for the outgoing packet, this determines
985the alias address to be used.
986If no mapping exists, then a default address, usually the address of the
987packet aliasing host, is used.
988If necessary, this default address can be changed as often as each individual
989packet arrives.
990.Pp
991The aliasing port number is determined such that the new dynamic link does
992not conflict with any existing links.
993In the default operating mode, the packet aliasing engine attempts to set
994the aliasing port equal to the local port number.
995If this results in a conflict, then port numbers are randomly chosen until
996a unique aliasing link can be established.
997In an alternate operating mode, the first choice of an aliasing port is also
998random and unrelated to the local port number.
999.Sh MODULAR ARCHITECTURE Po AND Xr ipfw 4 SUPPORT Pc
1000One of the latest improvements to
1001.Nm
1002was to make its support
1003for new protocols independent from the rest of the library, giving it
1004the ability to load/unload support for new protocols at run-time.
1005To achieve this feature, all the code for protocol handling was moved
1006to a series of modules outside of the main library.
1007These modules are compiled from the same sources but work in
1008different ways, depending on whether they are compiled to work inside a kernel
1009or as part of the userland library.
1010.Ss LIBALIAS MODULES IN KERNEL LAND
1011When compiled for the kernel,
1012.Nm
1013modules are plain KLDs recognizable with the
1014.Pa alias_
1015prefix.
1016.Pp
1017To add support for a new protocol, load the corresponding module.
1018For example:
1019.Pp
1020.Dl "kldload alias_ftp"
1021.Pp
1022When support for a protocol is no longer needed, its module can be unloaded:
1023.Pp
1024.Dl "kldunload alias_ftp"
1025.Ss LIBALIAS MODULES IN USERLAND
1026Due to the differences between kernel and userland (no KLD mechanism,
1027many different address spaces, etc.), we had to change a bit how to
1028handle module loading/tracking/unloading in userland.
1029.Pp
1030While compiled for a userland
1031.Nm ,
1032all the modules are plain libraries, residing in
1033.Pa /usr/lib ,
1034and recognizable with the
1035.Pa libalias_
1036prefix.
1037.Pp
1038There is a configuration file,
1039.Pa /etc/libalias.conf ,
1040with the following contents (by default):
1041.Bd -literal -offset indent
1042/usr/lib/libalias_ftp.so
1043/usr/lib/libalias_irc.so
1044/usr/lib/libalias_nbt.so
1045/usr/lib/libalias_pptp.so
1046/usr/lib/libalias_skinny.so
1047/usr/lib/libalias_smedia.so
1048.Ed
1049.Pp
1050This file contains the paths to the modules that
1051.Nm
1052will load.
1053To load/unload a new module, just add its path to
1054.Pa libalias.conf
1055and call
1056.Fn LibAliasRefreshModules
1057from the program.
1058In case the application provides a
1059.Dv SIGHUP
1060signal handler, add a call to
1061.Fn LibAliasRefreshModules
1062inside the handler, and every time you want to refresh the loaded modules,
1063send it the
1064.Dv SIGHUP
1065signal:
1066.Pp
1067.Dl "kill -HUP <process_pid>"
1068.Ss MODULAR ARCHITECURE: HOW IT WORKS
1069The modular architecture of
1070.Nm
1071works similar whether it is running inside the
1072kernel or in userland.
1073From
1074.Pa alias_mod.c :
1075.Bd -literal
1076/* Protocol and userland module handlers chains. */
1077LIST_HEAD(handler_chain, proto_handler) handler_chain ...
1078\&...
1079SLIST_HEAD(dll_chain, dll) dll_chain ...
1080.Ed
1081.Pp
1082.Va handler_chain
1083keeps track of all the protocol handlers loaded, while
1084.Va ddl_chain
1085tracks which userland modules are loaded.
1086.Pp
1087.Va handler_chain
1088is composed of
1089.Vt "struct proto_handler"
1090entries:
1091.Bd -literal
1092struct proto_handler {
1093	u_int pri;
1094	int16_t dir;
1095	uint8_t proto;
1096	int (*fingerprint)(struct libalias *la,
1097		 struct ip *pip, struct alias_data *ah);
1098	int (*protohandler)(struct libalias *la,
1099		 struct ip *pip, struct alias_data *ah);
1100	TAILQ_ENTRY(proto_handler) link;
1101};
1102.Ed
1103.Pp
1104where:
1105.Bl -inset
1106.It Va pri
1107is the priority assigned to a protocol handler; lower priority
1108is better.
1109.It Va dir
1110is the direction of packets: ingoing or outgoing.
1111.It Va proto
1112indicates to which protocol this packet belongs: IP, TCP or UDP.
1113.It Va fingerprint
1114points to the fingerprint function while protohandler points
1115to the protocol handler function.
1116.El
1117.Pp
1118The
1119.Va fingerprint
1120function has the dual role of checking if the
1121incoming packet is found, and if it belongs to any categories that this
1122module can handle.
1123.Pp
1124The
1125.Va protohandler
1126function actually manipulates
1127the packet to make
1128.Nm
1129correctly NAT it.
1130.Pp
1131When a packet enters
1132.Nm ,
1133if it meets a module hook,
1134.Va handler_chain
1135is searched to see if there is an handler that matches
1136this type of a packet (it checks protocol and direction of packet).
1137Then, if more than one handler is found, it starts with the module with
1138the lowest priority number: it calls the
1139.Va fingerprint
1140function and interprets the result.
1141.Pp
1142If the result value is equal to 0 then it calls the protocol handler
1143of this handler and returns.
1144Otherwise, it proceeds to the next eligible module until the
1145.Va handler_chain
1146is exhausted.
1147.Pp
1148Inside
1149.Nm ,
1150the module hook looks like this:
1151.Bd -literal -offset indent
1152struct alias_data ad = {
1153	lnk,
1154	&original_address,
1155	&alias_address,
1156	&alias_port,
1157	&ud->uh_sport,          /* original source port */
1158	&ud->uh_dport,		/* original dest port */
1159	256                     /* maxpacketsize */
1160};
1161
1162\&...
1163
1164/* walk out chain */
1165err = find_handler(IN, UDP, la, pip, &ad);
1166.Ed
1167.Pp
1168All data useful to a module are gathered together in an
1169.Vt alias_data
1170structure, then
1171.Fn find_handler
1172is called.
1173The
1174.Fn find_handler
1175function is responsible for walking the handler
1176chain; it receives as input parameters:
1177.Bl -tag -width indent
1178.It Fa IN
1179direction
1180.It Fa UDP
1181working protocol
1182.It Fa la
1183pointer to this instance of libalias
1184.It Fa pip
1185pointer to a
1186.Vt "struct ip"
1187.It Fa ad
1188pointer to
1189.Vt "struct alias_data"
1190(see above)
1191.El
1192.Pp
1193In this case,
1194.Fn find_handler
1195will search only for modules registered for
1196supporting INcoming UDP packets.
1197.Pp
1198As was mentioned earlier,
1199.Nm
1200in userland is a bit different, as
1201care must be taken in module handling as well (avoiding duplicate load of
1202modules, avoiding modules with same name, etc.) so
1203.Va dll_chain
1204was introduced.
1205.Pp
1206.Va dll_chain
1207contains a list of all userland
1208.Nm
1209modules loaded.
1210.Pp
1211When an application calls
1212.Fn LibAliasRefreshModules ,
1213.Nm
1214first unloads all the loaded modules, then reloads all the modules listed in
1215.Pa /etc/libalias.conf :
1216for every module loaded, a new entry is added to
1217.Va dll_chain .
1218.Pp
1219.Va dll_chain
1220is composed of
1221.Vt "struct dll"
1222entries:
1223.Bd -literal
1224struct dll {
1225	/* name of module */
1226	char            name[DLL_LEN];
1227	/*
1228	 * ptr to shared obj obtained through
1229	 * dlopen() - use this ptr to get access
1230	 * to any symbols from a loaded module
1231	 * via dlsym()
1232	 */
1233	void            *handle;
1234	struct dll      *next;
1235};
1236.Ed
1237.Bl -inset
1238.It Va name
1239is the name of the module.
1240.It Va handle
1241is a pointer to the module obtained through
1242.Xr dlopen 3 .
1243.El
1244Whenever a module is loaded in userland, an entry is added to
1245.Va dll_chain ,
1246then every protocol handler present in that module
1247is resolved and registered in
1248.Va handler_chain .
1249.Ss HOW TO WRITE A MODULE FOR LIBALIAS
1250There is a module (called
1251.Pa alias_dummy.[ch] )
1252in
1253.Nm
1254that can be used as a skeleton for future work.
1255Here we analyse some parts of that module.
1256From
1257.Pa alias_dummy.c :
1258.Bd -literal
1259struct proto_handler handlers[] = {
1260    {
1261	.pri = 666,
1262	.dir = IN|OUT,
1263	.proto = UDP|TCP,
1264	.fingerprint = fingerprint,
1265	.protohandler= protohandler,
1266    },
1267    { EOH }
1268};
1269.Ed
1270.Pp
1271The variable
1272.Va handlers
1273is the
1274.Dq "most important thing"
1275in a module
1276since it describes the handlers present and lets the outside world use
1277it in an opaque way.
1278.Pp
1279It must ALWAYS be present in every module, and it MUST retain
1280the name
1281.Va handlers ,
1282otherwise attempting to load a module in userland will fail and
1283complain about missing symbols: for more information about module
1284load/unload, please refer to
1285.Fn LibAliasRefreshModules ,
1286.Fn LibAliasLoadModule
1287and
1288.Fn LibAliasUnloadModule
1289in
1290.Pa alias.c .
1291.Pp
1292.Va handlers
1293contains all the
1294.Vt proto_handler
1295structures present in a module.
1296.Bd -literal
1297static int
1298mod_handler(module_t mod, int type, void *data)
1299{
1300	int error;
1301
1302	switch (type) {
1303	case MOD_LOAD:
1304		error = LibAliasAttachHandlers(handlers);
1305		break;
1306	case MOD_UNLOAD:
1307		error = LibAliasDetachHandlers(handlers);
1308		break;
1309	default:
1310		error = EINVAL;
1311	}
1312	return (error);
1313}
1314.Ed
1315When running as KLD,
1316.Fn mod_handler
1317registers/deregisters the module using
1318.Fn LibAliasAttachHandlers
1319and
1320.Fn LibAliasDetachHandlers ,
1321respectively.
1322.Pp
1323Every module must contain at least 2 functions: one fingerprint
1324function and a protocol handler function.
1325.Bd -literal
1326#ifdef _KERNEL
1327static
1328#endif
1329int
1330fingerprint(struct libalias *la, struct ip *pip, struct alias_data *ah)
1331{
1332
1333\&...
1334}
1335
1336#ifdef _KERNEL
1337static
1338#endif
1339int
1340protohandler(struct libalias *la, struct ip *pip,
1341             struct alias_data *ah)
1342{
1343
1344\&...
1345}
1346.Ed
1347and they must accept exactly these input parameters.
1348.Ss PATCHING AN APPLICATION FOR USERLAND LIBALIAS MODULES
1349To add module support into an application that uses
1350.Nm ,
1351the following simple steps can be followed.
1352.Bl -enum
1353.It
1354Find the main file of an application
1355(let us call it
1356.Pa main.c ) .
1357.It
1358Add this to the header section of
1359.Pa main.c ,
1360if not already present:
1361.Pp
1362.Dl "#include <signal.h>"
1363.Pp
1364and this just after the header section:
1365.Pp
1366.Dl "static void signal_handler(int);"
1367.It
1368Add the following line to the init function of an application or,
1369if it does not have any init function, put it in
1370.Fn main :
1371.Pp
1372.Dl "signal(SIGHUP, signal_handler);"
1373.Pp
1374and place the
1375.Fn signal_handler
1376function somewhere in
1377.Pa main.c :
1378.Bd -literal -offset indent
1379static void
1380signal_handler(int sig)
1381{
1382
1383	LibAliasRefreshModules();
1384}
1385.Ed
1386.Pp
1387Otherwise, if an application already traps the
1388.Dv SIGHUP
1389signal, just add a call to
1390.Fn LibAliasRefreshModules
1391in the signal handler function.
1392.El
1393For example, to patch
1394.Xr natd 8
1395to use
1396.Nm
1397modules, just add the following line to
1398.Fn RefreshAddr "int sig __unused" :
1399.Pp
1400.Dl "LibAliasRefreshModules()"
1401.Pp
1402recompile and you are done.
1403.Ss LOGGING SUPPORT IN KERNEL LAND
1404When working as KLD,
1405.Nm
1406now has log support that
1407happens on a buffer allocated inside
1408.Vt "struct libalias"
1409(from
1410.Pa alias_local.h ) :
1411.Bd -literal
1412struct libalias {
1413       ...
1414
1415	/* log descriptor        */
1416#ifdef	KERNEL_LOG
1417	char           *logDesc;        /*
1418					 * ptr to an auto-malloced
1419					 * memory buffer when libalias
1420					 * works as kld
1421					 */
1422#else
1423	FILE           *logDesc;	/*
1424					 * ptr to /var/log/alias.log
1425					 * when libalias runs as a
1426					 * userland lib
1427					 */
1428#endif
1429
1430	...
1431}
1432.Ed
1433so all applications using
1434.Nm
1435will be able to handle their
1436own logs, if they want, accessing
1437.Va logDesc .
1438Moreover, every change to a log buffer is automatically added to
1439.Xr syslog 3
1440with the
1441.Dv LOG_SECURITY
1442facility and the
1443.Dv LOG_INFO
1444level.
1445.Sh AUTHORS
1446.An Charles Mott Aq cm@linktel.net ,
1447versions 1.0 - 1.8, 2.0 - 2.4.
1448.An Eivind Eklund Aq eivind@FreeBSD.org ,
1449versions 1.8b, 1.9 and 2.5.
1450Added IRC DCC support as well as contributing a number of architectural
1451improvements; added the firewall bypass for FTP/IRC DCC.
1452.An Erik Salander Aq erik@whistle.com
1453added support for PPTP and RTSP.
1454.An Junichi Satoh Aq junichi@junichi.org
1455added support for RTSP/PNA.
1456.An Ruslan Ermilov Aq ru@FreeBSD.org
1457added support for PPTP and LSNAT as well as general hacking.
1458.An Gleb Smirnoff Aq glebius@FreeBSD.org
1459ported the library to kernel space.
1460.An Paolo Pisati Aq piso@FreeBSD.org
1461made the library modular, moving support for all
1462protocols (except for IP, TCP and UDP) to external modules.
1463.Sh ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
1464Listed below, in approximate chronological order, are individuals who
1465have provided valuable comments and/or debugging assistance.
1466.Bd -ragged -offset indent
1467.An -split
1468.An Gary Roberts
1469.An Tom Torrance
1470.An Reto Burkhalter
1471.An Martin Renters
1472.An Brian Somers
1473.An Paul Traina
1474.An Ari Suutari
1475.An Dave Remien
1476.An J. Fortes
1477.An Andrzej Bialecki
1478.An Gordon Burditt
1479.Ed
1480