1afb33690SMurray Stokely.\" Copyright (c) 2002 Murray Stokely <murray@FreeBSD.org> 2afb33690SMurray Stokely.\" All rights reserved. 3de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" 4de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without 5de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions 6de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" are met: 7de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" 1. Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright 8de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer. 9de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" 2. Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright 10de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer in the 11de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" documentation and/or other materials provided with the distribution. 12de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" 13de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED BY THE AUTHOR ``AS IS'' AND 14de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE 15de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE 16de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" ARE DISCLAIMED. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHOR BE LIABLE 17de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, EXEMPLARY, OR CONSEQUENTIAL 18de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" DAMAGES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, PROCUREMENT OF SUBSTITUTE GOODS 19de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" OR SERVICES; LOSS OF USE, DATA, OR PROFITS; OR BUSINESS INTERRUPTION) 20de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" HOWEVER CAUSED AND ON ANY THEORY OF LIABILITY, WHETHER IN CONTRACT, STRICT 21de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" LIABILITY, OR TORT (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE OR OTHERWISE) ARISING IN ANY WAY 22de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" OUT OF THE USE OF THIS SOFTWARE, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF 23de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" SUCH DAMAGE. 24de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" 25de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" $FreeBSD$ 26de26e0adSMurray Stokely.\" 27de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Dd March 12, 2002 28de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Dt RELEASE 7 29de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Os 30de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Sh NAME 31de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Nm release 32afb33690SMurray Stokely.Nd "release building infrastructure" 33de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Sh DESCRIPTION 34de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Fx 35de26e0adSMurray Stokelyprovides a complete build environment suitable for users to make 36de26e0adSMurray Stokelyfull releases of the 37de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Fx 38994c71f0SMurray Stokelyoperating system. 39de26e0adSMurray StokelyAll of the tools necessary to build a release are available from the 40de26e0adSMurray StokelyCVS repository in 41de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Pa src/release . 42de26e0adSMurray StokelyA complete release can actually be built with only a single command, 43eee69fccSMurray Stokelyincluding the creation of ISO images suitable for burning to CD-ROM, 44de26e0adSMurray Stokelyinstallation floppies, and an FTP install directory. 45de26e0adSMurray StokelyThis command is aptly named 46afb33690SMurray Stokely.Dq Li "make release" . 47de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Pp 48de26e0adSMurray StokelyBefore attempting to build a release, the user is expected to be 49994c71f0SMurray Stokelyfamiliar with the contents of 50de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr build 7 , 51de26e0adSMurray Stokelyand should have experience upgrading systems from source with 52afb33690SMurray Stokely.Dq Li "make world" . 53de26e0adSMurray StokelyThe release build process requires that 54de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Pa /usr/obj 55de26e0adSMurray Stokelybe populated with the output of 56afb33690SMurray Stokely.Dq Li "make buildworld" . 57de26e0adSMurray StokelyThis is necessary so that the object files for a complete system can 58de26e0adSMurray Stokelybe installed into a clean 59de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr chroot 8 60de26e0adSMurray Stokelyenvironment. 61de26e0adSMurray StokelyThe release procedure also requires that the 62994c71f0SMurray Stokely.Xr md 4 63994c71f0SMurray Stokely(memory disk) device driver be present in the kernel 64994c71f0SMurray Stokely(either by being compiled in or loaded as a module). 65de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Pp 66de26e0adSMurray StokelyThis document does not cover source code management, quality 67de26e0adSMurray Stokelyassurance, or other aspects of the release engineering process. 68de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Sh TARGETS 69de26e0adSMurray StokelyThe release makefile 70994c71f0SMurray Stokely.Pq Pa src/release/Makefile 71de26e0adSMurray Stokelyis fairly abstruse. 72de26e0adSMurray StokelyMost developers will only be concerned with the 73afb33690SMurray Stokely.Cm release 74de26e0adSMurray Stokelytarget. 75994c71f0SMurray Stokely.\" XXX: Some sort of introduction to this list? All the others have one. 76afb33690SMurray Stokely.Bl -tag -width ".Cm rerelease" 77afb33690SMurray Stokely.It Cm release 78de26e0adSMurray StokelyUses 79afb33690SMurray Stokely.Dq Li "make installworld" 80de26e0adSMurray Stokelyto install a clean system into a 81de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr chroot 8 82de26e0adSMurray Stokelyenvironment on the filesystem. 83de26e0adSMurray StokelyChecks out the specified version of the source code and then rebuilds 84de26e0adSMurray Stokelythe entire system in the clean environment with 85afb33690SMurray Stokely.Dq Li "make world" . 86de26e0adSMurray StokelyThe detailed steps that follow are then executed to package up the 87de26e0adSMurray Stokelydifferent distributions, build the installation floppy disks, build 88de26e0adSMurray Stokelyrelease documentation, and so on. 89afb33690SMurray Stokely.It Cm rerelease 90de26e0adSMurray StokelyAssumes that the output of a release build has been manually modified, 91de26e0adSMurray Stokelyand performs the minimal number of steps to rebuild the release using 92de26e0adSMurray Stokelythe intermediate output of the previous 93afb33690SMurray Stokely.Dq Li "make release" . 94eee69fccSMurray Stokely.It Cm floppies 95eee69fccSMurray StokelyGenerate a new set of boot floppies. 96eee69fccSMurray StokelyThis will call the 97eee69fccSMurray Stokely.Cm release.4 , 98eee69fccSMurray Stokely.Cm release.8 , 99eee69fccSMurray Stokelyand 100eee69fccSMurray Stokely.Cm release.9 101eee69fccSMurray Stokelytargets to re-generate the floppy images of a previous 102eee69fccSMurray Stokely.Dq Li "make release" . 103eee69fccSMurray StokelyThis is most often used to build custom boot floppies. 104de26e0adSMurray Stokely.El 105de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Pp 106de26e0adSMurray StokelyTargets called by 107afb33690SMurray Stokely.Dq Li "make release" : 108afb33690SMurray Stokely.Bl -tag -width ".Cm release.9" 109afb33690SMurray Stokely.It Cm release.1 110de26e0adSMurray StokelyCleans out the 111de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Pa ${CHROOTDIR}/R 112de26e0adSMurray Stokelydirectory and uses 113afb33690SMurray Stokely.Xr mtree 8 114de26e0adSMurray Stokelyto build the directory hierarchy for the system. 115afb33690SMurray Stokely.It Cm release.2 116de26e0adSMurray StokelyInstalls the system into the distribution directories. 117afb33690SMurray Stokely.It Cm release.3 118eee69fccSMurray Stokely.\" XXX: We build more than one kernel. We build a stripped down 119eee69fccSMurray Stokely.\" kernel for the boot media in addition to a full GENERIC kernel. 120994c71f0SMurray StokelyMakes and installs the 121994c71f0SMurray Stokely.Pa GENERIC 122994c71f0SMurray Stokelykernel. 123afb33690SMurray Stokely.It Cm release.4 124de26e0adSMurray StokelyUses 125de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr crunchgen 1 126de26e0adSMurray Stokelyto build 127afb33690SMurray Stokely.Dq crunched 128de26e0adSMurray Stokelybinaries to live on the installation floppies. 129afb33690SMurray Stokely.It Cm release.5 130de26e0adSMurray StokelyBuilds synthetic distributions, and cleans up the previously built 131de26e0adSMurray Stokelydistribution trees. 132afb33690SMurray Stokely.It Cm release.6 133de26e0adSMurray StokelyCreates tarballs of the assembled distribution trees. 134afb33690SMurray Stokely.It Cm release.7 135de26e0adSMurray StokelyMakes source distributions. 136afb33690SMurray Stokely.It Cm release.8 137de26e0adSMurray StokelyCreates the boot and MFS root floppies. 138afb33690SMurray Stokely.It Cm release.9 139de26e0adSMurray StokelyCreates the fixit floppy. 140afb33690SMurray Stokely.It Cm ftp.1 141eee69fccSMurray StokelySets up a suitable area for FTP installations in 142eee69fccSMurray Stokely.Pa ${CHROOTDIR}/R/ftp . 143afb33690SMurray Stokely.It Cm cdrom.1 144eee69fccSMurray StokelySets up a suitable area to build CD-ROM images in 145eee69fccSMurray Stokely.Pa ${CHROOTDIR}/R/cdrom . 146afb33690SMurray Stokely.It Cm iso.1 147de26e0adSMurray StokelyBuilds two ISO images (installation and 148afb33690SMurray Stokely.Dq live 149eee69fccSMurray Stokelyfilesystem) from the CD-ROM release area 1501bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely(disabled by default, see 1511bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.Va MAKE_ISOS 152994c71f0SMurray Stokelybelow). 153afb33690SMurray Stokely.It Cm doc.1 154994c71f0SMurray StokelyBuilds all of the necessary tools to turn the 155994c71f0SMurray Stokely.Fx 156994c71f0SMurray StokelyDocumentation Project source documents (SGML, XML) into HTML 157994c71f0SMurray Stokelyand text documents that will accompany the release. 158994c71f0SMurray StokelyAlso, builds and installs the actual user documentation. 159994c71f0SMurray StokelyThis includes the Handbook, FAQ, articles, and so on. 160afb33690SMurray Stokely.It Cm doc.2 161994c71f0SMurray StokelyBuilds the release documentation. 162994c71f0SMurray StokelyThis includes the release notes, 163de26e0adSMurray Stokelyhardware guide, and installation instructions. 164de26e0adSMurray Stokely.El 165de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Sh ENVIRONMENT 166994c71f0SMurray StokelyVariables that must be specified: 167afb33690SMurray Stokely.Bl -tag -width ".Va RELEASETAG" 1681bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.It Va CHROOTDIR 169de26e0adSMurray StokelyThe directory to be used as the 170de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr chroot 8 171de26e0adSMurray Stokelyenvironment for the entire release build. 172994c71f0SMurray Stokely.\" XXX: I recommend against hardcoding specific numbers like "2.3" here; 173994c71f0SMurray Stokely.\" XXX: perhaps it should be replaced with something to the effect of 174994c71f0SMurray Stokely.\" XXX: "we don't know how much space you'll need, but make sure you have 175994c71f0SMurray Stokely.\" XXX: at least 3 GB to be safe" (I know i'm still hardcoding a number, 176994c71f0SMurray Stokely.\" XXX: but at least it looks less like a decree and more like an estimate. 177de26e0adSMurray StokelyThis filesystem should have at least 2.3 gigabytes of free space on the 178de26e0adSMurray Stokelyi386 architecture. 1791bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.It Va BUILDNAME 180994c71f0SMurray StokelyThe name of the release to be built. 181994c71f0SMurray StokelyThis is used to set the 1821bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.Va RELEASE 183de26e0adSMurray Stokelyvalue in 184de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Pa sys/conf/newvers.sh , 185de26e0adSMurray Stokelywhich affects the output of 186de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr uname 1 . 1871bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.It Va CVSROOT 188994c71f0SMurray StokelyThe location of the 189994c71f0SMurray Stokely.Fx 190994c71f0SMurray StokelyCVS repository. 191eee69fccSMurray StokelyThis path name is referenced to the real system root, 192eee69fccSMurray Stokely.Em not 193eee69fccSMurray Stokelythe root of the 194eee69fccSMurray Stokely.Xr chroot 8 195eee69fccSMurray Stokelydirectory tree. 1961bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.It Va RELEASETAG 197994c71f0SMurray StokelyThe CVS tag corresponding to the release that is to be built. 198afb33690SMurray StokelyIf undefined, the release will be built from the 199afb33690SMurray Stokely.Dv HEAD 200afb33690SMurray Stokelyof the CVS tree 201de26e0adSMurray Stokely(a 2021bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.Dq "-CURRENT snapshot" ) . 203de26e0adSMurray Stokely.El 204de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Pp 205de26e0adSMurray StokelyOptional variables: 2061bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.Bl -tag -width ".Va RELEASEDISTFILES" 2071bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.It Va LOCAL_PATCHES 208de26e0adSMurray StokelyA patch file against 209de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Pa /usr/src 210de26e0adSMurray Stokelythat will be applied in the 211de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr chroot 8 212de26e0adSMurray Stokelyenvironment before the release build begins. 2131bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.It Va PATCH_FLAGS 214de26e0adSMurray StokelyArguments for the 215de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr patch 1 216de26e0adSMurray Stokelycommand used to apply 2171bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.Va LOCAL_PATCHES 218afb33690SMurray Stokelypatch file. 219eee69fccSMurray Stokely.It Va LOCAL_SCRIPT 220eee69fccSMurray StokelyA script that will be run in the 221eee69fccSMurray Stokely.Xr chroot 8 222eee69fccSMurray Stokelyenvironment immediately after any local patches are applied. 2231bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.It Va MAKE_ISOS 224eee69fccSMurray StokelyIf defined, bootable ISO CD-ROM images will be created from the 225eee69fccSMurray Stokelycontents of the CD-ROM stage directory. 2261bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.It Va NODOC 227de26e0adSMurray StokelyIf set to 228eee69fccSMurray Stokely.Dq Li YES , 229eee69fccSMurray Stokelythe SGML-based documentation from the 230de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Fx 231eee69fccSMurray StokelyDocumentation Project will not be built. 232eee69fccSMurray StokelyHowever, the 233eee69fccSMurray Stokely.Dq doc 234eee69fccSMurray Stokelydistribution will still be created with the minimal documentation set 235eee69fccSMurray Stokelyprovided in 236eee69fccSMurray Stokely.Pa src/share/doc . 2371bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.It Va NOPORTS 238de26e0adSMurray StokelyIf set to 239afb33690SMurray Stokely.Dq Li YES 240eee69fccSMurray Stokelythen the Ports Collection will be omitted from the release. 241eee69fccSMurray Stokely.It Va NOPORTREADMES 242eee69fccSMurray StokelyIt defined, readme files will not be created for each individual port 243eee69fccSMurray Stokelyin the Ports Collection. 244eee69fccSMurray StokelyThe default behavior is for 245eee69fccSMurray Stokely.Dq Li "make release" 246eee69fccSMurray Stokelyto run 247eee69fccSMurray Stokely.Dq Li "make readmes" 248eee69fccSMurray Stokelyfrom 249eee69fccSMurray Stokely.Pa ${CHROOTDIR}/usr/ports , 250eee69fccSMurray Stokelywhich can be a very time consuming operation. 2511bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.It Va RELEASEDISTFILES 252de26e0adSMurray StokelyThe directory where the distribution files for ports required by the 253de26e0adSMurray Stokelyrelease build can be found. 254de26e0adSMurray StokelyThis may save a significant amount of time over downloading the 255de26e0adSMurray Stokelydistfiles through a slow link. 2561bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.It Va RELEASENOUPDATE 257de26e0adSMurray StokelyIf this variable is defined for 258afb33690SMurray Stokely.Dq Li "make rerelease" , 259de26e0adSMurray Stokelythe source code will not be updated with 260afb33690SMurray Stokely.Dq Li "cvs update" . 261de26e0adSMurray Stokely.El 262de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Sh FILES 263de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Bl -tag -compact 264de26e0adSMurray Stokely.It Pa /etc/make.conf 265de26e0adSMurray Stokely.It Pa /usr/doc/Makefile 266de26e0adSMurray Stokely.It Pa /usr/doc/share/mk/doc.project.mk 267de26e0adSMurray Stokely.It Pa /usr/ports/Mk/bsd.port.mk 268de26e0adSMurray Stokely.It Pa /usr/ports/Mk/bsd.sites.mk 269de26e0adSMurray Stokely.It Pa /usr/share/examples/etc/make.conf 270de26e0adSMurray Stokely.It Pa /usr/src/Makefile 271de26e0adSMurray Stokely.It Pa /usr/src/Makefile.inc1 272de26e0adSMurray Stokely.It Pa /usr/src/release/Makefile 273de26e0adSMurray Stokely.It Pa /usr/src/release/${arch}/drivers.conf 274de26e0adSMurray Stokely.It Pa /usr/src/release/${arch}/boot_crunch.conf 275de26e0adSMurray Stokely.It Pa /usr/src/release/${arch}/fixit_crunch.conf 276de26e0adSMurray Stokely.El 277de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Sh EXAMPLES 278994c71f0SMurray StokelyThe following sequence of commands was used to build the 279de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Fx 4.5 280de26e0adSMurray Stokelyrelease: 281de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Bd -literal -offset indent 282de26e0adSMurray Stokelycd /usr 283de26e0adSMurray Stokelycvs co -rRELENG_4_5_0_RELEASE src 284de26e0adSMurray Stokelycd src 285de26e0adSMurray Stokelymake buildworld 286de26e0adSMurray Stokelycd release 287de26e0adSMurray Stokelymake release CHROOTDIR=/local3/release BUILDNAME=4.5-RELEASE \\ 288de26e0adSMurray Stokely CVSROOT=/host/cvs/usr/home/ncvs RELEASETAG=RELENG_4_5_0_RELEASE 289de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Ed 290de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Pp 291de26e0adSMurray StokelyAfter running these commands, a complete system suitable for FTP or 292eee69fccSMurray StokelyCD-ROM distribution is available in the 293994c71f0SMurray Stokely.Pa /local3/release/R 294de26e0adSMurray Stokelydirectory. 295de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Pp 296994c71f0SMurray StokelyThe following sequence of commands can be used to build a 2971bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.Dq "-CURRENT snapshot" 298994c71f0SMurray Stokelyof a 299de26e0adSMurray Stokelylocally modified source tree: 300de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Bd -literal -offset indent 301de26e0adSMurray Stokelycd /usr/src 302de26e0adSMurray Stokelycvs diff -u > /path/to/local.patch 303de26e0adSMurray Stokelymake buildworld 304de26e0adSMurray Stokelycd release 305eee69fccSMurray Stokelymake release CHROOTDIR=/local3/release BUILDNAME=5.0-CURRENT \\ 306de26e0adSMurray Stokely CVSROOT=/host/cvs/usr/home/ncvs LOCAL_PATCHES=/path/to/local.patch 307de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Ed 308de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Sh SEE ALSO 309de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr cc 1 , 310de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr crunchgen 1 , 311afb33690SMurray Stokely.Xr cvs 1 , 312de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr install 1 , 313de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr make 1 , 314de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr patch 1 , 315de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr uname 1 , 316afb33690SMurray Stokely.Xr md 4 , 317de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr make.conf 5 , 318de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr build 7 , 319de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Xr ports 7 , 320afb33690SMurray Stokely.Xr chroot 8 , 321afb33690SMurray Stokely.Xr mtree 8 322994c71f0SMurray Stokely.Rs 3231bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.%T "FreeBSD Release Engineering" 324994c71f0SMurray Stokely.%O http://www.FreeBSD.org/doc/en_US.ISO8859-1/articles/releng/ 325994c71f0SMurray Stokely.Re 326994c71f0SMurray Stokely.Rs 3271bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.%T "FreeBSD Release Engineering of Third Party Packages" 328994c71f0SMurray Stokely.%O http://www.FreeBSD.org/doc/en_US.ISO8859-1/articles/releng-packages/ 329994c71f0SMurray Stokely.Re 330994c71f0SMurray Stokely.Rs 3311bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.%T "FreeBSD Developers' Handbook" 332994c71f0SMurray Stokely.%O http://www.FreeBSD.org/doc/en_US.ISO8859-1/books/developers-handbook/ 333994c71f0SMurray Stokely.Re 334de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Sh HISTORY 335de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Fx 336de26e0adSMurray Stokely1.x 3371bcf2f1aSMurray Stokelyused a manual checklist, compiled by 3381bcf2f1aSMurray Stokely.An Rod Grimes , 3391bcf2f1aSMurray Stokelyto produce a release. 340de26e0adSMurray StokelyApart from being incomplete, the list put a lot of specific demands on 341de26e0adSMurray Stokelyavailable filesystems and was quite torturous to execute. 342de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Pp 343994c71f0SMurray StokelyAs part of the 344994c71f0SMurray Stokely.Fx 2.0 345994c71f0SMurray Stokelyrelease engineering effort, significant 346de26e0adSMurray Stokelyeffort was spent getting 347de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Pa src/release/Makefile 348de26e0adSMurray Stokelyinto a shape where it could at least automate most of the tediousness 349de26e0adSMurray Stokelyof building a release in a sterile environment. 350de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Pp 351afb33690SMurray StokelyWith its almost 1000 revisions spread over multiple branches, the 352afb33690SMurray Stokely.Xr cvs 1 353994c71f0SMurray Stokelylog of 354994c71f0SMurray Stokely.Pa src/release/Makefile 355994c71f0SMurray Stokelycontains a vivid historical record of some 356de26e0adSMurray Stokelyof the hardships release engineers go through. 357de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Sh AUTHORS 358de26e0adSMurray Stokely.Pa src/release/Makefile 359afb33690SMurray Stokelywas originally written by 360afb33690SMurray Stokely.An -nosplit 361afb33690SMurray Stokely.An Rod Grimes , 362afb33690SMurray Stokely.An Jordan Hubbard , 363afb33690SMurray Stokelyand 364afb33690SMurray Stokely.An Poul-Henning Kamp . 365994c71f0SMurray StokelyThis manual page was written by 366de26e0adSMurray Stokely.An Murray Stokely Aq murray@FreeBSD.org . 367