xref: /freebsd/sbin/routed/routed.8 (revision 4f8f43b06ed07e96a250855488cc531799d5b78f)
1.\"   $Revision: 2.26 $
2.\"
3.\" Copyright (c) 1983, 1991, 1993
4.\"	The Regents of the University of California.  All rights reserved.
5.\"
6.\" Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without
7.\" modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions
8.\" are met:
9.\" 1. Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright
10.\"    notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer.
11.\" 2. Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright
12.\"    notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer in the
13.\"    documentation and/or other materials provided with the distribution.
14.\" 3. Neither the name of the University nor the names of its contributors
15.\"    may be used to endorse or promote products derived from this software
16.\"    without specific prior written permission.
17.\"
18.\" THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED BY THE REGENTS AND CONTRIBUTORS ``AS IS'' AND
19.\" ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE
20.\" IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE
21.\" ARE DISCLAIMED.  IN NO EVENT SHALL THE REGENTS OR CONTRIBUTORS BE LIABLE
22.\" FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, EXEMPLARY, OR CONSEQUENTIAL
23.\" DAMAGES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, PROCUREMENT OF SUBSTITUTE GOODS
24.\" OR SERVICES; LOSS OF USE, DATA, OR PROFITS; OR BUSINESS INTERRUPTION)
25.\" HOWEVER CAUSED AND ON ANY THEORY OF LIABILITY, WHETHER IN CONTRACT, STRICT
26.\" LIABILITY, OR TORT (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE OR OTHERWISE) ARISING IN ANY WAY
27.\" OUT OF THE USE OF THIS SOFTWARE, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF
28.\" SUCH DAMAGE.
29.\"
30.\"     @(#)routed.8	8.2 (Berkeley) 12/11/93
31.\"
32.Dd June 27, 2022
33.Dt ROUTED 8
34.Os
35.Sh NAME
36.Nm routed ,
37.Nm rdisc
38.Nd network RIP and router discovery routing daemon
39.Sh SYNOPSIS
40.Nm
41.Op Fl isqdghmpAtv
42.Op Fl T Ar tracefile
43.Oo
44.Fl F
45.Ar net Ns Op /mask Ns Op ,metric
46.Oc
47.Op Fl P Ar parms
48.Sh DESCRIPTION
49The
50.Nm
51utility is a daemon invoked at boot time to manage the network
52routing tables.
53It uses Routing Information Protocol, RIPv1 (RFC\ 1058),
54RIPv2 (RFC\ 1723),
55and Internet Router Discovery Protocol (RFC 1256)
56to maintain the kernel routing table.
57The RIPv1 protocol is based on the reference
58.Bx 4.3
59daemon.
60.Pp
61It listens on the
62.Xr udp 4
63socket for the
64.Xr route 8
65service (see
66.Xr services 5 )
67for Routing Information Protocol packets.
68It also sends and receives multicast Router Discovery ICMP messages.
69If the host is a router,
70.Nm
71periodically supplies copies
72of its routing tables to any directly connected hosts and networks.
73It also advertises or solicits default routes using Router Discovery
74ICMP messages.
75.Pp
76When started (or when a network interface is later turned on),
77.Nm
78uses an AF_ROUTE address family facility to find those
79directly connected interfaces configured into the
80system and marked "up".
81It adds necessary routes for the interfaces
82to the kernel routing table.
83Soon after being first started, and provided there is at least one
84interface on which RIP has not been disabled,
85.Nm
86deletes all pre-existing
87non-static routes in kernel table.
88Static routes in the kernel table are preserved and
89included in RIP responses if they have a valid RIP -hopcount
90(see
91.Xr route 8 ) .
92.Pp
93If more than one interface is present (not counting the loopback interface),
94it is assumed that the host should forward packets among the
95connected networks.
96After transmitting a RIP
97.Em request
98and
99Router Discovery Advertisements or Solicitations on a new interface,
100the daemon enters a loop, listening for
101RIP request and response and Router Discovery packets from other hosts.
102.Pp
103When a
104.Em request
105packet is received,
106.Nm
107formulates a reply based on the information maintained in its
108internal tables.
109The
110.Em response
111packet generated contains a list of known routes, each marked
112with a "hop count" metric (a count of 16 or greater is
113considered "infinite").
114The advertised metric for a route reflects the metrics associated
115with interfaces
116(see
117.Xr ifconfig 8 )
118though which it is received and sent,
119so setting the metric on an interface
120is an effective way to steer traffic.
121See also
122.Cm adj_inmetric
123and
124.Cm adj_outmetric
125parameters below.
126.Pp
127Responses do not include routes with a first hop on the requesting
128network to implement in part
129.Em split-horizon .
130Requests from query programs
131such as
132.Xr rtquery 8
133are answered with the complete table.
134.Pp
135The routing table maintained by the daemon
136includes space for several gateways for each destination
137to speed recovery from a failing router.
138RIP
139.Em response
140packets received are used to update the routing tables provided they are
141from one of the several currently recognized gateways or
142advertise a better metric than at least one of the existing
143gateways.
144.Pp
145When an update is applied,
146.Nm
147records the change in its own tables and updates the kernel routing table
148if the best route to the destination changes.
149The change in the kernel routing table is reflected in the next batch of
150.Em response
151packets sent.
152If the next response is not scheduled for a while, a
153.Em flash update
154response containing only recently changed routes is sent.
155.Pp
156In addition to processing incoming packets,
157.Nm
158also periodically checks the routing table entries.
159If an entry has not been updated for 3 minutes, the entry's metric
160is set to infinity and marked for deletion.
161Deletions are delayed until the route has been advertised with
162an infinite metric to ensure the invalidation
163is propagated throughout the local internet.
164This is a form of
165.Em poison reverse .
166.Pp
167Routes in the kernel table that are added or changed as a result
168of ICMP Redirect messages are deleted after a while to minimize
169.Em black-holes .
170When a TCP connection suffers a timeout,
171the kernel tells
172.Nm ,
173which deletes all redirected routes
174through the gateway involved, advances the age of all RIP routes through
175the gateway to allow an alternate to be chosen, and advances of the
176age of any relevant Router Discovery Protocol default routes.
177.Pp
178Hosts acting as internetwork routers gratuitously supply their
179routing tables every 30 seconds to all directly connected hosts
180and networks.
181These RIP responses are sent to the broadcast address on nets that support
182broadcasting,
183to the destination address on point-to-point links, and to the router's
184own address on other networks.
185If RIPv2 is enabled, multicast packets are sent on interfaces that
186support multicasting.
187.Pp
188If no response is received on a remote interface, if there are errors
189while sending responses,
190or if there are more errors than input or output (see
191.Xr netstat 1 ) ,
192then the cable or some other part of the interface is assumed to be
193disconnected or broken, and routes are adjusted appropriately.
194.Pp
195The
196.Em Internet Router Discovery Protocol
197is handled similarly.
198When the daemon is supplying RIP routes, it also listens for
199Router Discovery Solicitations and sends Advertisements.
200When it is quiet and listening to other RIP routers, it
201sends Solicitations and listens for Advertisements.
202If it receives
203a good Advertisement and it is not multi-homed,
204it stops listening for broadcast or multicast RIP responses.
205It tracks several advertising routers to speed recovery when the
206currently chosen router dies.
207If all discovered routers disappear,
208the daemon resumes listening to RIP responses.
209It continues listening to RIP while using Router Discovery
210if multi-homed to ensure all interfaces are used.
211.Pp
212The Router Discovery standard requires that advertisements
213have a default "lifetime" of 30 minutes.
214That means should
215something happen, a client can be without a good route for
21630 minutes.
217It is a good idea to reduce the default to 45
218seconds using
219.Fl P Cm rdisc_interval=45
220on the command line or
221.Cm rdisc_interval=45
222in the
223.Pa /etc/gateways
224file.
225.Pp
226While using Router Discovery (which happens by default when
227the system has a single network interface and a Router Discover Advertisement
228is received), there is a single default route and a variable number of
229redirected host routes in the kernel table.
230On a host with more than one network interface,
231this default route will be via only one of the interfaces.
232Thus, multi-homed hosts running with
233.Fl q
234might need
235.Cm no_rdisc
236described below.
237.Pp
238See the
239.Cm pm_rdisc
240facility described below to support "legacy" systems
241that can handle neither RIPv2 nor Router Discovery.
242.Pp
243By default, neither Router Discovery advertisements nor solicitations
244are sent over point to point links (e.g.\& PPP).
245The netmask associated with point-to-point links (such as SLIP
246or PPP, with the IFF_POINTOPOINT flag) is used by
247.Nm
248to infer the netmask used by the remote system when RIPv1 is used.
249.Pp
250The following options are available:
251.Bl -tag -width indent
252.It Fl i
253allow
254.Nm
255to accept a RIP request from non-router node.
256When specified once,
257.Nm
258replies to a route information query from neighbor nodes.
259When specified twice,
260it replies to a query from remote nodes in addition.
261.Xr rtquery 8
262utility can be used to send a request.
263.Pp
264This feature is disabled by default because of a risk of reflection attack
265though it is useful for debugging purpose.
266.It Fl s
267force
268.Nm
269to supply routing information.
270This is the default if multiple network interfaces are present on which
271RIP or Router Discovery have not been disabled, and if the kernel switch
272ipforwarding=1.
273.It Fl q
274is the opposite of the
275.Fl s
276option.
277This is the default when only one interface is present.
278With this explicit option, the daemon is always in "quiet-mode" for RIP
279and does not supply routing information to other computers.
280.It Fl d
281do not run in the background.
282This option is meant for interactive use.
283.It Fl g
284used on internetwork routers to offer a route
285to the "default" destination.
286It is equivalent to
287.Fl F
288.Cm 0/0,1
289and is present mostly for historical reasons.
290A better choice is
291.Fl P Cm pm_rdisc
292on the command line or
293.Cm pm_rdisc
294in the
295.Pa /etc/gateways
296file,
297since a larger metric
298will be used, reducing the spread of the potentially dangerous
299default route.
300This is typically used on a gateway to the Internet,
301or on a gateway that uses another routing protocol whose routes
302are not reported to other local routers.
303Notice that because a metric of 1 is used, this feature is
304dangerous.
305It is more commonly accidentally used to create chaos with a
306routing loop than to solve problems.
307.It Fl h
308cause host or point-to-point routes to not be advertised,
309provided there is a network route going the same direction.
310That is a limited kind of aggregation.
311This option is useful on gateways to Ethernets that have other gateway
312machines connected with point-to-point links such as SLIP.
313.It Fl m
314cause the machine to advertise a host or point-to-point route to
315its primary interface.
316It is useful on multi-homed machines such as NFS servers.
317This option should not be used except when the cost of
318the host routes it generates is justified by the popularity of
319the server.
320It is effective only when the machine is supplying
321routing information, because there is more than one interface.
322The
323.Fl m
324option overrides the
325.Fl q
326option to the limited extent of advertising the host route.
327.It Fl A
328do not ignore RIPv2 authentication if we do not care about RIPv2
329authentication.
330This option is required for conformance with RFC 1723.
331However, it makes no sense and breaks using RIP as a discovery protocol
332to ignore all RIPv2 packets that carry authentication when this machine
333does not care about authentication.
334.It Fl t
335increase the debugging level, which causes more information to be logged
336on the tracefile specified with
337.Fl T
338or standard out.
339The debugging level can be increased or decreased
340with the
341.Em SIGUSR1
342or
343.Em SIGUSR2
344signals or with the
345.Xr rtquery 8
346command.
347.It Fl T Ar tracefile
348increases the debugging level to at least 1 and
349causes debugging information to be appended to the trace file.
350Note that because of security concerns, it is wisest to not run
351.Nm
352routinely with tracing directed to a file.
353.It Fl v
354display and logs the version of daemon.
355.It Fl F Ar net[/mask][,metric]
356minimize routes in transmissions via interfaces with addresses that match
357.Em net/mask ,
358and synthesizes a default route to this machine with the
359.Em metric .
360The intent is to reduce RIP traffic on slow, point-to-point links
361such as PPP links by replacing many large UDP packets of RIP information
362with a single, small packet containing a "fake" default route.
363If
364.Em metric
365is absent, a value of 14 is assumed to limit
366the spread of the "fake" default route.
367This is a dangerous feature that when used carelessly can cause routing
368loops.
369Notice also that more than one interface can match the specified network
370number and mask.
371See also
372.Fl g .
373.It Fl P Ar parms
374is equivalent to adding the parameter
375line
376.Em parms
377to the
378.Pa /etc/gateways
379file.
380.El
381.Pp
382Any other argument supplied is interpreted as the name
383of a file in which the actions of
384.Nm
385should be logged.
386It is better to use
387.Fl T
388instead of
389appending the name of the trace file to the command.
390.Pp
391The
392.Nm
393utility also supports the notion of
394"distant"
395.Em passive
396or
397.Em active
398gateways.
399When
400.Nm
401is started, it reads the file
402.Pa /etc/gateways
403to find such distant gateways which may not be located using
404only information from a routing socket, to discover if some
405of the local gateways are
406.Em passive ,
407and to obtain other parameters.
408Gateways specified in this manner should be marked passive
409if they are not expected to exchange routing information,
410while gateways marked active
411should be willing to exchange RIP packets.
412Routes through
413.Em passive
414gateways are installed in the
415kernel's routing tables once upon startup and are not included in
416transmitted RIP responses.
417.Pp
418Distant active gateways are treated like network interfaces.
419RIP responses are sent
420to the distant
421.Em active
422gateway.
423If no responses are received, the associated route is deleted from
424the kernel table and RIP responses advertised via other interfaces.
425If the distant gateway resumes sending RIP responses, the associated
426route is restored.
427.Pp
428Such gateways can be useful on media that do not support broadcasts
429or multicasts but otherwise act like classic shared media like
430Ethernets such as some ATM networks.
431One can list all RIP routers reachable on the HIPPI or ATM network in
432.Pa /etc/gateways
433with a series of
434"host" lines.
435Note that it is usually desirable to use RIPv2 in such situations
436to avoid generating lists of inferred host routes.
437.Pp
438Gateways marked
439.Em external
440are also passive, but are not placed in the kernel
441routing table nor are they included in routing updates.
442The function of external entries is to indicate
443that another routing process
444will install such a route if necessary,
445and that other routes to that destination should not be installed
446by
447.Nm .
448Such entries are only required when both routers may learn of routes
449to the same destination.
450.Pp
451The
452.Pa /etc/gateways
453file is comprised of a series of lines, each in
454one of the following two formats or consist of parameters described later.
455Blank lines and lines starting with '#' are comments.
456.Bd -ragged
457.Cm net
458.Ar Nname[/mask]
459.Cm gateway
460.Ar Gname
461.Cm metric
462.Ar value
463.Pf < Cm passive No \&|
464.Cm active No \&|
465.Cm extern Ns >
466.Ed
467.Bd -ragged
468.Cm host
469.Ar Hname
470.Cm gateway
471.Ar Gname
472.Cm metric
473.Ar value
474.Pf < Cm passive No \&|
475.Cm active No \&|
476.Cm extern Ns >
477.Ed
478.Pp
479.Ar Nname
480or
481.Ar Hname
482is the name of the destination network or host.
483It may be a symbolic network name or an Internet address
484specified in "dot" notation (see
485.Xr inet 3 ) .
486(If it is a name, then it must either be defined in
487.Pa /etc/networks
488or
489.Pa /etc/hosts ,
490or a method in
491.Xr nsswitch.conf 5
492must be able to resolve it.)
493.Pp
494.Ar Mask
495is an optional number between 1 and 32 indicating the netmask associated
496with
497.Ar Nname .
498.Pp
499.Ar Gname
500is the name or address of the gateway to which RIP responses should
501be forwarded.
502.Pp
503.Ar Value
504is the hop count to the destination host or network.
505.Pp
506.Cm Host Ar hname
507is equivalent to
508.Cm net Ar nname/32 .
509.Pp
510One of the keywords
511.Cm passive ,
512.Cm active
513or
514.Cm external
515must be present to indicate whether the gateway should be treated as
516.Cm passive
517or
518.Cm active
519(as described above),
520or whether the gateway is
521.Cm external
522to the scope of the RIP protocol.
523.Pp
524As can be seen when debugging is turned on with
525.Fl t ,
526such lines create pseudo-interfaces.
527To set parameters for remote or external interfaces,
528a line starting with
529.Cm if=alias(Hname) ,
530.Cm if=remote(Hname) ,
531etc.\& should be used.
532.Ss Parameters
533Lines that start with neither "net" nor "host" must consist of one
534or more of the following parameter settings, separated by commas or
535blanks:
536.Bl -tag -width indent
537.It Cm if Ns = Ns Ar ifname
538indicates that the other parameters on the line apply to the interface
539name
540.Ar ifname .
541.It Cm subnet Ns = Ns Ar nname Ns Oo / Ns Ar mask Oc Ns Op , Ns Ar metric
542advertises a route to network
543.Ar nname
544with mask
545.Ar mask
546and the supplied metric (default 1).
547This is useful for filling "holes" in CIDR allocations.
548This parameter must appear by itself on a line.
549The network number must specify a full, 32-bit value, as in 192.0.2.0
550instead of 192.0.2.
551.Pp
552Do not use this feature unless necessary.
553It is dangerous.
554.It Cm ripv1_mask Ns = Ns Ar nname Ns / Ns Ar mask1 , Ns Ar mask2
555specifies that netmask of the network of which
556.Ar nname Ns / Ns Ar mask1
557is
558a subnet should be
559.Ar mask2 .
560For example,
561.Dq Li ripv1_mask=192.0.2.16/28,27
562marks 192.0.2.16/28
563as a subnet of 192.0.2.0/27 instead of 192.0.2.0/24.
564It is better to turn on RIPv2 instead of using this facility, for example
565with
566.Cm ripv2_out .
567.It Cm passwd Ns = Ns Ar XXX[|KeyID[start|stop]]
568specifies a RIPv2 cleartext password that will be included on
569all RIPv2 responses sent, and checked on all RIPv2 responses received.
570Any blanks, tab characters, commas, or '#', '|', or NULL characters in the
571password must be escaped with a backslash (\\).
572The common escape sequences \\n, \\r, \\t, \\b, and \\xxx have their
573usual meanings.
574The
575.Cm KeyID
576must be unique but is ignored for cleartext passwords.
577If present,
578.Cm start
579and
580.Cm stop
581are timestamps in the form year/month/day@hour:minute.
582They specify when the password is valid.
583The valid password with the most future is used on output packets, unless
584all passwords have expired, in which case the password that expired most
585recently is used, or unless no passwords are valid yet, in which case
586no password is output.
587Incoming packets can carry any password that is valid, will
588be valid within the next 24 hours, or that was valid within the preceding
58924 hours.
590To protect the secrets, the passwd settings are valid only in the
591.Pa /etc/gateways
592file and only when that file is readable only by UID 0.
593.It Cm md5_passwd Ns \&= Ns Ar XXX|KeyID[start|stop]
594specifies a RIPv2 MD5 password.
595Except that a
596.Cm KeyID
597is required, this keyword is similar to
598.Cm passwd .
599.It Cm no_ag
600turns off aggregation of subnets in RIPv1 and RIPv2 responses.
601.It Cm no_super_ag
602turns off aggregation of networks into supernets in RIPv2 responses.
603.It Cm passive
604marks the interface to not be advertised in updates sent via other
605interfaces, and turns off all RIP and router discovery through the interface.
606.It Cm no_rip
607disables all RIP processing on the specified interface.
608If no interfaces are allowed to process RIP packets,
609.Nm
610acts purely as a router discovery daemon.
611.Pp
612Note that turning off RIP without explicitly turning on router
613discovery advertisements with
614.Cm rdisc_adv
615or
616.Fl s
617causes
618.Nm
619to act as a client router discovery daemon, not advertising.
620.It Cm no_rip_mcast
621causes RIPv2 packets to be broadcast instead of multicast.
622.It Cm no_rip_out
623causes no RIP updates to be sent.
624.It Cm no_ripv1_in
625causes RIPv1 received responses to be ignored.
626.It Cm no_ripv2_in
627causes RIPv2 received responses to be ignored.
628.It Cm ripv2_out
629turns on RIPv2 output and causes RIPv2 advertisements to be
630multicast when possible.
631.It Cm ripv2
632is equivalent to
633.Cm no_ripv1_in
634and
635.Cm no_ripv1_out .
636This enables RIPv2.
637.It Cm no_rdisc
638disables the Internet Router Discovery Protocol.
639.It Cm no_solicit
640disables the transmission of Router Discovery Solicitations.
641.It Cm send_solicit
642specifies that Router Discovery solicitations should be sent,
643even on point-to-point links,
644which by default only listen to Router Discovery messages.
645.It Cm no_rdisc_adv
646disables the transmission of Router Discovery Advertisements.
647.It Cm rdisc_adv
648specifies that Router Discovery Advertisements should be sent,
649even on point-to-point links,
650which by default only listen to Router Discovery messages.
651.It Cm bcast_rdisc
652specifies that Router Discovery packets should be broadcast instead of
653multicast.
654.It Cm rdisc_pref Ns \&= Ns Ar N
655sets the preference in Router Discovery Advertisements to the optionally
656signed integer
657.Ar N .
658The default preference is 0.
659Default routes with smaller or more negative preferences are preferred by
660clients.
661.It Cm rdisc_interval Ns \&= Ns Ar N
662sets the nominal interval with which Router Discovery Advertisements
663are transmitted to N seconds and their lifetime to 3*N.
664.It Cm fake_default Ns \&= Ns Ar metric
665has an identical effect to
666.Fl F Ar net[/mask][=metric]
667with the network and mask coming from the specified interface.
668.It Cm pm_rdisc
669is similar to
670.Cm fake_default .
671When RIPv2 routes are multicast, so that RIPv1 listeners cannot
672receive them, this feature causes a RIPv1 default route to be
673broadcast to RIPv1 listeners.
674Unless modified with
675.Cm fake_default ,
676the default route is broadcast with a metric of 14.
677That serves as a "poor man's router discovery" protocol.
678.It Cm adj_inmetric Ns \&= Ns Ar delta
679adjusts the hop count or metric of received RIP routes by
680.Ar delta .
681The metric of every received RIP route is increased by the sum
682of two values associated with the interface.
683One is the adj_inmetric value and the other is the interface
684metric set with
685.Xr ifconfig 8 .
686.It Cm adj_outmetric Ns \&= Ns Ar delta
687adjusts the hop count or metric of advertised RIP routes by
688.Ar delta .
689The metric of every received RIP route is increased by the metric
690associated with the interface by which it was received, or by 1 if
691the interface does not have a non-zero metric.
692The metric of the received route is then increased by the
693adj_outmetric associated with the interface.
694Every advertised route is increased by a total of four
695values,
696the metric set for the interface by which it was received with
697.Xr ifconfig 8 ,
698the
699.Cm adj_inmetric Ar delta
700of the receiving interface,
701the metric set for the interface by which it is transmitted with
702.Xr ifconfig 8 ,
703and the
704.Cm adj_outmetric Ar delta
705of the transmitting interface.
706.It Cm trust_gateway Ns \&= Ns Ar rname[|net1/mask1|net2/mask2|...]
707causes RIP packets from router
708.Ar rname
709and other routers named in other
710.Cm trust_gateway
711keywords to be accepted, and packets from other routers to be ignored.
712If networks are specified, then routes to other networks will be ignored
713from that router.
714.It Cm redirect_ok
715allows the kernel to listen ICMP Redirect messages when the system is acting
716as a router and forwarding packets.
717Otherwise, ICMP Redirect messages are overridden and deleted when the
718system is acting as a router.
719.El
720.Sh FILES
721.Bl -tag -width /etc/gateways -compact
722.It Pa /etc/gateways
723for distant gateways
724.El
725.Sh SEE ALSO
726.Xr icmp 4 ,
727.Xr udp 4 ,
728.Xr rtquery 8
729.Rs
730.%T Internet Transport Protocols
731.%R XSIS 028112
732.%Q Xerox System Integration Standard
733.Re
734.Sh HISTORY
735The
736.Nm
737utility appeared in
738.Bx 4.2 .
739.\"  LocalWords:  loopback ICMP rtquery ifconfig multicasting Solicitations RIPv
740.\"  LocalWords:  netstat rdisc
741.Sh BUGS
742It does not always detect unidirectional failures in network interfaces,
743for example, when the output side fails.
744